Thursday, January 13, 2011

Dear The Atlantic, We Have Opinions

When I was applying to medical school, a big part of my spiel was on the importance of connecting the medical profession to the outside world by those inside the community (in my case, I wanted to do it via writing).  It's quite easy and tempting to speak candidly and frequently with colleagues, who by definition share our professional backgrounds: we are trained similarly, learn similar material, undergo similar challenges on the job, face similar frustrations, and basically just "understand" what it's like in fewer words.  It's more of a challenge to communicate to those without a similar professional currency.  It's time, it's effort, it's frankly patience that can sometimes be difficult to muster.

But the alternative is to have those outside the community describing to others outside the community what it's like from inside the community.  And sometimes it's misleading, or hits on precisely the wrong points... or both.  If we do not have the time to write, we should at least correct such misinterpretations:

In September 2009, The Atlantic published a piece on teaching ethics to medical students.

The premise was that medical students were getting a surprisingly inadequate foundation in ethics, buttressed by a study published in JAMA by Mayo researchers.  Used as major support for the article's premise was a startling statistic apparently found in the Mayo study:
Also surprising was the study's finding that only 14% of those students had an opinion about "appropriate interactions between physicians and pharmaceutical companies." How could 86% of medical students not even have an opinion on such a hot subject? 
The short answer is, they don't.  The study did not find that students did not have opinions on these issues; rather it found that students "frequently had opinions inconsistent with the AMA policy on conflicts of interest in relationship with [pharmaceutical] industry."  When researchers presented scenarios to students, "only 14%... of students' opinions on relationships with industry aligned with the AMA policy of all 6 scenarios."  Only about 5%--not 86%, as the journalist claims--did not answer at least one of the industry questions.  So, about 5% of students have at best "incomplete" opinions and at worst no opinions on industry.

We may not agree with the AMA, but we do have opinions.  Quite a difference.

Perhaps most disheartening is the fact that this result was in the abstract of the paper, right under Results.  It is accessible to all and is a mere 342 words long.  (This blog post is 417 words long.)


  1. However,what you should bethink is that the action of louis vuitton replica the backpack does not depend on the amount or the designer”it depends on what you use and how you use it.These types of bags,if acclimated properly,can accompany out your inner,a lot of hidden beauty.No amount how big-ticket a artist backpack is,it cannot accomplish this if it is not acclimated properly.Broad replica handbags and gucci replica broad artist aggressive handbags can be your best appearance accessory.However,to be able to acquisition the appropriate artefact you should buck in apperception a few things.They will accomplish your seek simpler and accomplish abiding the replica watch you buy is altogether inline with your needs.Firstly,one should authorize his charge as to why he wants to buy a watch.Ask yourself if you accept to abrasion it for your plan or do you wish one for accidental wear.This is what will advice you to focus your seek and save your time aswell as there are endless replica watches accessible and it gets actual harder to achieve on one if you do not apperceive as to replica watches why you charge one.Likewise,you should accept an abstraction about your budget.If it is bound you may accept to achieve for low end replica watches while if you can acquiesce to absorb some money,you can calmly buy a top superior replica watch.One can aswell attending for abatement offers in case he wants to save money.

  2. Oahu is the best blend of vintage and also modern day types. rolex replica sale Created together with complex finesse, these kinds of timepieces show love and also brilliance. Men’s timepieces typically have got analog knobs. fake cartier watches Several characteristic roman quantities, even though the other folks have got Language digits. A number of the exceptional kinds have got Devanagari quantities which usually enhance their particular elegance. cartier replica sale Women’s assortment characteristic fragile timepieces decorated together with girlie highlights just like studs, pearls and also fragile models. fake tag heuer Several accessory designed kinds have got ethnic seem. Several characteristic knobs possessing gorgeous flowered models. fake rolex uk Several hold the knobs offering strict highlights just like Om or perhaps Ganesh. The particular Rare metal units will be the best birthday or perhaps wedding party items for your young couples.